Louise Bloomfield
← Campaign news

tasmanian courts ·

Tasmania's Courts Are Already Overloaded. It Is Time to Shut the Door on Fake Law.

Behind court delays are real Tasmanians waiting for resolution. Practical steps to reject baseless pseudolaw can help protect public court resources and ensure timely access to justice.

Text reading 'Soveriegn Citizen Law Its time Tasmania addressed it' over a modern geometric building facade.

Tasmania's courts are struggling with serious backlogs, leaving victims, families and defendants waiting months or even years for justice. Yet valuable court resources can still be consumed by people insisting that Australian laws simply do not apply to them.

Victoria has recently taken action against so-called sovereign citizen arguments. Tasmania should follow its lead.

In September 2026, the Victorian Supreme Court introduced a practice note allowing registry staff to reject documents relying on pseudolaw. These are legal-sounding arguments that have repeatedly been rejected by Australian courts.

They include claims that a person can separate themselves from their legal identity, that legislation requires individual consent, or that obscure historical documents override modern Australian law.

The message is straightforward. Courts exist to administer justice, not endlessly debate invented legal theories.

Tasmania cannot afford unnecessary delays.

The scale of Tasmania's court backlog should concern everyone.

At 30 June 2025, the Magistrates Court had 11,426 adult criminal matters awaiting completion. Almost 20 per cent were more than 12 months old.

In the Supreme Court, 48 per cent of pending civil matters were older than 12 months.

These are not simply administrative statistics. Behind every delayed proceeding are people waiting for answers, businesses carrying legal costs, victims seeking resolution and defendants whose lives remain on hold.

In August 2026, the Tasmanian Government released an independent review containing 20 recommendations to address court delays, accepting 19 fully or in principle.

That work is welcome, but surely we should also examine unnecessary demands being placed on our courts.

The problem with sovereign citizen arguments

Sovereign citizens generally assert that they can withdraw their consent from Australian law and thereby escape obligations such as taxation, vehicle registration, fines or court orders.

In September, NSW Chief Justice Andrew Bell addressed the misuse of judicial proceedings by those promoting pseudolaw, highlighting how the courts can become a platform for arguments entirely disconnected from legitimate legal disputes.

The Australian Taxation Office has confronted similar claims.

Its Taxpayer Alert TA 2016/5 warned about arrangements involving purportedly tax-exempt private foundations, promoted as ways to avoid ordinary taxation obligations.

Giving a business an impressive title or creating elaborate paperwork does not remove its obligations under Australian tax law.

There are legitimate ways to challenge tax assessments, structure businesses and minimise taxation. Declaring yourself outside Australian law is not one of them.

Unfortunately, some promoters make money selling these supposed loopholes, leaving their followers exposed to substantial financial and legal consequences.

A practical reform for Tasmania

Tasmania should examine the Victorian Supreme Court's approach and consider introducing equivalent practice directions, with appropriate powers and safeguards, across its court system.

Documents relying entirely on previously rejected pseudolegal arguments could be identified early, rather than automatically proceeding through costly legal processes.

Where necessary, a judicial officer could review disputed rejections to ensure legitimate cases are not excluded.

This would not prevent people representing themselves, challenging government decisions or exercising their legal rights.

It would simply recognise that repeatedly rejected legal theories should not receive unlimited opportunities to consume public resources.

We should also be realistic. Sovereign citizen proceedings are not the principal documented cause of Tasmania's court backlog, and no evidence currently establishes how much hearing time such proceedings consume locally.

But that is precisely why Tasmania should measure the problem and consider sensible preventative measures.

Justice delayed is justice denied

Every unnecessary hour spent dealing with baseless legal arguments is an hour potentially unavailable to someone with a genuine matter requiring resolution.

Our courts must remain accessible, but accessibility should never be confused with an unrestricted right to obstruct proceedings.

Tasmania needs more efficient courts, appropriate resources and practical reforms that protect everyone's access to justice.

The Victorian approach offers another measure worth examining.

Our judicial system should protect the right to challenge the law, while recognising that no individual can simply declare themselves exempt from it.

When our courts are already struggling to deliver timely justice, Tasmania cannot afford to treat judicial resources as unlimited.